Fayetteville, Tennessee
Cookies,
made wiser.
Hand-decorated cookie cakes and small-batch cookies, baked from scratch with the good stuff. Every order is reviewed and accepted personally, for local pickup & delivery.
Our Flavors
Baked fresh, your way
Choose from our classic favorites or try something special. Every cookie is made to order with love.
Classics
Premium
The Menu
Made from scratch,
decorated by hand
Soft, sweet, and baked to order. Tap any cookie to start a request. Every order is reviewed and accepted personally.
Cookie Cake
14" roundOur signature giant cookie — one big round that serves a crowd, decorated and ready to celebrate.
Decorated Sugar Cookies
Soft sugar cookies, hand-iced for your theme, from clean and simple to fully bespoke.
Cookie Bites
2" roundsTwo-inch minis perfect for the classroom, baby showers, and parties, sold by the dozen.
Drops
Limited little-batch drops
Single 4" cookie cakes for special occasions like Mother's Day or Teacher Appreciation. They don't happen often and they don't last long, so grab one while it's live.
This week's drop
4" cookie cakes
Single-serve cookie cakes released for the occasion. We'll show how many are left. First come, first served, and every request is accepted personally.
4" Cookie Cake
Classic flavor
4" Cookie Cake
Premium flavor
Our Story
Baked at home, shared with our town
Wiser Cookie Co. began in a small Tennessee kitchen with a whisk, a love of decorating, and a whole lot of patience. Every order is mixed, baked, and hand-finished to order.
We bake in small batches so each cookie gets the attention it deserves, and we love giving back to the community and first responders who keep us going.
With love,
the Wiser kitchen
Local Pickup
Where to find us
Pick up your order at one of our local spots. We'll confirm the day and time with you once your order is accepted.
Wiser Cookie Co.
117 Good Hollow Rd Taft, TN 38488KB AG Supply
1811 Wilson Pkwy Fayetteville, TN 37334Weekday pickup only
Shop Taylor & Company
111 Main Ave N Fayetteville, TN 37334Pickup times confirmed at checkout
Once your order is accepted we'll message you the exact pickup day, time, and spot. Pay when you pick up.